Pick's Pub Menu (Update 2026)

Pick's Pub offers a diverse menu packed with delicious options sure to please any palate. With about 20 dishes to choose from, it’s easy to find something for everyone. The iconic fish fry stands out, a local favorite that keeps patrons returning for more. Chicken wings come in various flavors, perfect for sharing or enjoying solo. For those craving something hearty, the cheesesteak and onion ring burger topped with BBQ sauce hit the spot. Don't overlook the sweet potato fries and the delightful pickled dishes, ideal side options.

For a refreshing drink, their mango margarita pairs perfectly with any meal, enhancing the local dining experience.

Considering all these choices, it’s tough to skip dessert. The apple crisp makes for a sweet ending that locals rave about. Whether you visit for a casual lunch or a fun dinner with friends, Pick's Pub ensures every meal is satisfying.

Pick's Pub Menu image 1
Pick's Pub Menu image 2
Pick's Pub Menu image 3
Pick's Pub Menu image 4

Featured Dishes

Grilled Chicken Salad
Grilled Chicken Salad
Mango Margarita
Mango Margarita
Fish Sandwich
Fish Sandwich
Pickled Deviled Eggs
Pickled Deviled Eggs
Onion Ring Burger with BBQ Sauce
Onion Ring Burger with BBQ Sauce
Quesadilla
Quesadilla
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Apple Crisp
Apple Crisp
Bagel Breakfast Sandwich
Bagel Breakfast Sandwich
Chimichanga
Chimichanga
Peas and Carrots Rice and Mashed Potatoes
Peas and Carrots Rice and Mashed Potatoes
Turkey Club Sandwich as a Special for the Day
Turkey Club Sandwich as a Special for the Day
Oreo Cookie Dessert
Oreo Cookie Dessert
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Reuben Sandwich with Tater Tots
Reuben Sandwich with Tater Tots
Crispy Chicken Wrap
Crispy Chicken Wrap
Pickles with Ham and Cream Cheese
Pickles with Ham and Cream Cheese
14 Oz Queen Cut Prime Rib
14 Oz Queen Cut Prime Rib
Fish Fry Cole Slaw and Mac and Cheese
Fish Fry Cole Slaw and Mac and Cheese
3 Meatballs
3 Meatballs
Pick's Pub

Pick's Pub Interior, Food, Ambiance

Walk into Pick's Pub and feel the welcoming vibe right away. The spacious layout allows for comfortable seating, whether you’re gathering with friends or enjoying a meal solo. The warm decor features local memorabilia, making the space feel like a cherished community hub. It strikes a perfect balance between casual pub feel and cozy comfort.

As the aromas of sizzling dishes greet you, the ambiance invites relaxation. Sports fans often gather here to catch games, lending an energetic spirit to the evenings. With its inviting atmosphere and delicious food, Pick's Pub is not just a place to eat, it’s where the Elmira Heights community comes together.

Pick's Pub

About Pick's Pub Food and Specialties

At Pick's Pub, food takes center stage, with an emphasis on fresh ingredients and bold flavors. The menu features dishes that reflect comfort food with a twist. One standout item, the grilled chicken salad, combines healthiness with heartiness, catering to those looking for lighter fare. Pick’s Pub also offers a unique spin on traditional dishes, like pickled deviled eggs and the chimichanga, each item crafted to provide an unforgettable taste experience.

Portions are generous, ensuring no one leaves hungry. The variety in food options caters to various palates, making it an ideal spot for family gatherings or friendly hangouts. The attention to detail in every dish showcases a commitment to quality, making dining here a pleasure.

Pick's Pub

Pick's Pub commits to serving quality meals that satisfy and delight the taste buds. Specialties like the fish fry and chicken wings reflect a passion for good food crafted with care. The vision is to cultivate a space where everyone feels welcome, encouraging connections over shared meals. With an emphasis on generous portions and varied selections, Pick's Pub thrives as a local favorite. Celebrating the rich essence of Elmira Heights, the pub continually draws guests looking for great food and good times.